About the 2 Fish Inn

Fun, relaxing, warm, welcoming, and charming are just a few of the words often used to describe 2 Fish Inn. Over the years we’ve received complements from our guests from all over the world. For us, providing “old Florida” hospitality is just what it’s all about.

2 Fish Inn serves as the perfect getaway for someone looking for explore all that Pine Island and St. James City has to offer without all the hustle and bustle. It is also a warm and welcoming place for your pets. Whether you are looking to go boating, fishing, enjoy a drink at our tiki bar, or just relax by the pool, 2 Fish Inn delivers an experience with personality.

Some Wonderful Feedback from Our Guests

Sandi Pecaut
We just had the most wonderful time at 2 Fish Inn! We were so happy to find out we could book for just a couple days and didn’t have a 7 day minimum. We stayed in the Tarpon unit and it is absolutely adorable and has so many little extras that made our time on the island perfect! We loved having a keurig coffee machine and air fryer to use. Its so perfectly located that we could walk to most places we wanted to go. My husband spent all his free time fishing off the dock in back and caught snapper, sheep head and trout. We can’t wait to come back!
Hotel highlights: Great view, Quiet, Great value, High-tech
Rooms: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Location: 5/5

Kelly Knapke
We cannot say enough about this gem! Perfect location, perfect hosts, perfect rooms, need I go on. The photos you see are spot on. Thoroughly enjoyed our stay and highly recommend. Thank you all for a wonderful stay
Rooms: Great accommodations.
Walkability: I would not want to stay anywhere on the island after checking other areas out. Restaurants nearby along with kayak, bike and boat rental.
Hotel highlights: Quiet
Rooms: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Location: 5/5

Terry Sutton
2 Fish Inn is the real deal, top quality with attention to detail. The bed was amazing, the kitchen utensils included everything you need, towels & linens perfect. If you have a boat, you’re gonna love the NEW SLIPS..
The Hosts are super friendly and accommodating. I highly recommend you spending a few days.. Cheers
Rooms: Beautiful and updated, the furniture top quality, the bed, pillows & likeness, better than what I have a home.
Walkability: Very safe and super friendly community and ya gotta visit Froggys
Noteworthy details: 2 Fish Inn is everything you could want. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND
Hotel highlights: Luxury
Rooms: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Location: 5/5

Karon Merrick
Very clean, perfectly located Inn. The room was extremely well decorated with everything you could need. The pool was nice and if I had a boat the dock was just outside the door
Walkability: Restaurants and bars
Hotel highlights: Great view, Quiet
Rooms: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Location: 5/5

Dawk Hollister
The Two Fish Inn is awesome! We stayed there with our boat for a week and it couldn’t have been any better. Greg, Deb and the other owners are all super nice and helpful. The rooms are all clean, well appointed and we stayed nice and cool inside while it was 100+ degrees outside that week. We also enjoyed cooling down in the pool after being on the boat and had happy hour every evening under the Tiki. We cooked on the grill and in our room several nights and everything you need is right there. We were also a short walk to the bars/restaurants, and the Marina.
We will definitely be back, hopefully sooner rather than later.
Many thanks, Deb & Greg!
Dawk & Kristy Hollister
Hotel highlights: Great view, Quiet
Rooms: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Location: 5/5

Phylliss Van Tilburg
2 Fish Inn is charming, relaxing and beautifully remodeled after Hurrican Ian.
The owners are friendly and go out of their way to accommodate your needs. The canal offers great views of the dolphins and manatees swimming in the canal. The pool enclosure is perfect space to relax and the pool is heated.
The suites offer everything you need in the kitchen, linens and beach towels are included! There are several places to dine within walking distance. There is a dock for fishing and to secure your boat.
They offer coin operated laundry on site with new machines. We stayed here for 10 weeks and enjoyed every minute and plan to return next year!
Rooms: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Location: 5/5
Hotel highlights: Great view, Quiet, Kid-friendly

lisa ginivisian
The 2 Fish Inn is Pine Island’s best kept secret. Following the terrific hurricane that swept through this peaceful community less than two years ago, the 2 Fish Inn has built a feeling of comfortable renewal. Its thoughtfully designed units provided us with all the practical amenities aimed to please. There was a beverage nook with a variety of teas and coffees, a wine fridge and unique glasses to name a few. The kitchen equipped us with gadgets and appliances to make our own meals. The outdoor spaces featured colorful gardens, a tiki-hut and various seating that overlook the canal. This quiet oasis was perfect for our work and leisure activities and we enjoyed waving at the fishing boats and small yachts that strolled by us. The screened porch had plenty of lounge chairs and a well kept heated pool to cool off or to warm up. We basked in the sun and gazed at the stars while on the pool noodles that kept us afloat. When we lost track of time, the owner was flexible with our check-out so we never felt rushed. The location of this sanctuary was within walking distance to a few other small-owned businesses where we could get a fresh Grouper sandwich and a harbor view of the sunset. We’ll be back!
Hotel highlights: Quiet, Great value
Rooms: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Location: 5/5